Search
× Search
Friday, April 19, 2024

Archived Discussions

Recent member discussions

The Algorithmic Traders' Association prides itself on providing a forum for the publication and dissemination of its members' white papers, research, reflections, works in progress, and other contributions. Please Note that archive searches and some of our members' publications are reserved for members only, so please log in or sign up to gain the most from our members' contributions.

Can you recommend FX broker with good execution and low spread and commission? Monthly turnaround 50 mil.USD.. Interested in EURUSD mainly.

photo

 Martin M., Senior consultant at Microsoft

 Tuesday, August 27, 2013

I use JForex from a Swiss Broker currently. Everything works fine just paying $600 a month for a commission seems too high for me.


Print

3 comments on article "Can you recommend FX broker with good execution and low spread and commission? Monthly turnaround 50 mil.USD.. Interested in EURUSD mainly."

photo

 Jon Grah, Trading Systems Automation Expert @ AwarenessForex.com

 Thursday, August 29, 2013



IC Markets Au. I am an IB for them, but I trade a client's account and I can confirm the spreads for EURUSD are <0.4 pips 90% of the time. Many of the USD majors are < 0.6 on average and I see them go to 0-0.2 during busy periods. I push 100+ standard lots per month across 3 pairs and will probably increase to 300-500 lots over the next 1-2 months. That is "only" one small account.

Standard ECN commissions are 0.7 pips on a flat dollar schedule. In other words, $7 for every 1.00 lot traded, regardless of the base currency. Some brokers like FxOpen ECN will claim $5 per lot, but then it will be different for each non-usd base pair. Plus that $7 can be reduced to $5.50 or so by joining a rebate program or negotiating a better rate.

They claim to drop the commissions to $2-3 per round turn and API access if you can do 5,000+ lots monthly.

Global Prime Au is similar, but their spreads sometimes are 0.1 pip larger when IC-M is shorter.....but then there are times when GP is lower (but more often IC-M is slightly lower) and I can vouch somewhat for Gleneagle securities (sister company)

With some brokers, I was getting negative spreads on pairs like the AUDNZD, but mostly they have eliminated that because it was considered toxic order flow; they would peg it at 0 pips on the platform, which is fine by me to protect the liquidity provider.

I do agree with Alex that the total spread is about 1-1.2 pip round turn with commissions, for most majors USD pairs and major crosses are about 1.3-2.3; higher briefly after major news or low liquidity. I use a spread monitor to always get the best price. And my strategy slippage is usually positive anyway. You'd be surprised if you use certain retail STP brokers like IBFX that, with rebates, the spreads are not bad at all...at least on the USD majors.

Furthermore, I don't recommend shopping brokers ONLY based on commissions or a few tenths of a pip. You should be happy to pay $10 round turn per 1.00 lot if the broker is solid. Particularly if the broker has solid execution and is at your beckoning call when you have a technical, support, or withdraw request.

Swiss brokers like dukascopy have very high reputation AND a banking license. I do recommend spreading your money over multiple brokers (preferably in a different country or jurisdiction) to protect against counter-party risk. BUT, is a few 1/10s of a pip worth moving altogether?

edit: OP says 50 mil = 500 standard lots per month @ $600 commissions. That's $600 / 500 lots = $1.2 per lot ? or maybe I'm doing the math wrong.


photo

 Joe Bartelli, f/x broker at tullett/prebon

 Saturday, August 31, 2013



Tullett/Prebon is the best brokerage shop in Ny.


photo

 Praneet Kothavade, Equity Strategist at Macquarie Group

 Saturday, September 14, 2013



Checkout a new player in the market lucerahq.com, very fast, fully distributed and cloud based.

Please login or register to post comments.

TRADING FUTURES AND OPTIONS INVOLVES SUBSTANTIAL RISK OF LOSS AND IS NOT SUITABLE FOR ALL INVESTORS
Terms Of UsePrivacy StatementCopyright 2018 Algorithmic Traders Association